Don't take it personally

30.10.2007
kpennino
148

Article and Visual interpretation provided by Jennifer Johnson in Kristy Pennino’s Advanced Graphic Design II course.

Let’s face it we all have egos. We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style. One of the things that I struggled with especially when I first began classes at Valencia was getting defensive or taking comments about my projects too personally. Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind.

In my first couple of semesters at Valencia I learned about the dreaded portion of the process where, after I had worked on something for hours and days, I had to put my project on the board in front of everyone. Then I had to explain my ideas and listen to feedback offered by my fellow graphic design students. For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous. I have a fear of public speaking. Additionally that fear is increased when I think others might not like my work. Thankfully these days I am a lot more comfortable with that part of the design process, since it is something we have done in every Valencia course. It’s a good skill to develop a familiarity with, since it will be necessary when we are out working in the real world. I still get nervous though!

I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work. This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track. So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication.

Categories: achievements, general info

Comments

Posted: October 30, 2007 16:51

Kevin M. Scarbrough

When Paul Rand was presenting the IBM logo for the first time, an executive said it reminded him of Georgia's chain gang. No one's work is above reproach.

Reply
Posted: November 1, 2007 14:12

Elizabeth Vilella

When someone says "oh, that's nice" about your work, you soon learn that they have no idea what you are trying to accomplish. I'ts tough, your heart is on your sleeve when you are presenting your work, but I believe that if your message reads well, then there is no reason to fear. Besides, its not necessarily about you personally. Its about solving the problem. and yes "there is nothing to fear than fear itself" or something like that. :)

Reply
Posted: November 1, 2007 22:54

Alberto Serpilli

I am glad you surpassed this fear. I have had a hard time with critique too, I have always done my best but I have learned to take suggestions from other people, and at the same time it never hurts to try new things, at the end all you can do in learn more. Thanks I appreciate your writing.

Reply
Posted: November 2, 2007 18:06

barbara Muniz

We are all artists and is hard to let someone change our idea or message your are trying to send with your work, but is all part of it and at the end we will apreciate every single critique....

Reply
Posted: November 5, 2007 00:14

Raul Rubiano

I think when presenting is always important to show your idea to others and is very important to have people wanting to share their ideas about the idea you started with. After all, you coudlnt ask for much better feedback than more designers getting involved in your idea.

Reply
Posted: May 6, 2008 19:41

Tiffany Ramirez

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. I love constuctive criticism because it lets me know what to improve on even if I don't agree 100%. I always keep an open mind to other interpretations of my work and I sometimes find that a person's suggestions might make a difference for the better, Although I still have a fear of speaking in public.

Reply
Posted: May 7, 2008 10:31

Britini Surphlis

"taking comments about my projects too personally." This article was interesting to read and is very true. I know that when people are criticizing my work, I must keep remembering that they are trying to make it better. Another important aspect talked about in the article is if people are not understanding my ideas of the design, then I must try to make it better to show what my reason is for the design.

Reply
Posted: May 7, 2008 21:54

frances Barra

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." I think this is a great reminder for those receiving and those giving critiques. Both of these roles make me anxious. I understand the value of these, and therefore will learn through the process. From all that I've read, school is a much "safer" place to acquire these skills then the real world, so I am thankful that this is part of my educational process.

Reply
Posted: May 7, 2008 22:47

Virginia Carpenter

"Then I had to explain my ideas and listen to feedback offered by my fellow graphic design students." This is a very open and honest article. Personally, I enjoy critique. I like the fact that everyone sees things a little differently and I appreciate having people look at my work with a different eye. The part I do dread, however, is verbally having to explain my work. I've always been better at communicating through the written word or visually. I'm not a good verbal communicator, not because I get nervous, but just not a very articulate...

Reply
Posted: May 8, 2008 17:23

Gilberto Sanchez

"after I had worked on something for hours and days, I had to put my project on the board in front of everyone." I know exactly how this feels i had Design 1 last semester and after working hours on a project maybe even days i would stick the board in front of the class and listen to criticism. Although i was grateful for the criticism because it later helped me in my work. This article i think can relate to everyone because i think everyone has a little fear of criticism.

Reply
Posted: May 8, 2008 18:12

georgette torres

"When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." It is true that we learn more from experience than by others telling us what to do, but it is also true that sometimes by taking someones advice we can improve a lot of things without having to struggle so much Sometimes it happens that what works for someone may not work in the same quality for another person, but that is when we have to take the risk and try because experienced designers have a lot to give to us the beginners

Reply
Posted: May 8, 2008 21:46

Francisco

"For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous. I have a fear of public speaking. Additionally that fear is increased when I think others might not like my work." I agree with it. Most people go through the same thing, sort of like a fear of rejection work wise, at least, for me it is!! This is a weakness I know I will need to improve and I am currently working on it!

Reply
Posted: May 8, 2008 23:38

Janae' Britt

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." How can we, as designers, expect to create a masterpiece with only one point of view? A real piece of art is a collaborative effort of imagination, suggestion and work. We often forget how important criticism actually is, how valuable another point of view can be. I know I can feel the most defensive at the times when I know that I did not give 100%. Those are the times I must cling to critique, for it is one of the few ways I can improve my lousy first effort.

Reply
Posted: May 9, 2008 10:00

Allen Rayner

"I have a tendency to get defensive about my work" I think most Artist experience this emotion from time to time, We can become attached to something that we create and are pround of, but in the end it's all about perpective, and so while you might think your piece is great others might think differently. Critique helps us with that.

Reply
Posted: May 9, 2008 11:32

Jodi Miller

"This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track." I appreciate Ms. Johnson's article because the minute I heard "We will be critiquing each other's work" I became nervous. It's comforting to know that many of us feel defensive when our work is being critiqued, however it's equally comforting to know that these feelings are counterproductive because it gives me something to work on.

Reply
Posted: May 11, 2008 01:23

leah webb

Fortunately I have been through this process many times in the past. I took quite a few art classes in my day and honestly if you can't stand the heat get out of the kitchen! As graphic designers what we design has to please our supervisors, decision makers, clients, etc. and you will be critiqued on a daily basis. It's just the nature of the business. It sucks, that the world doesn't see everything the way I do, but most of the time I see the challenges, or requirements as a jumping board to creativity. When I weed out the things I can't or shouldn't do for a project it helps sharpen my vision and will take out all the excess clutter. As long as everyone (staff and students) alike show respect and a general concern for personal growth it can be a invaluable process that everyone can benefit from.

Reply
Posted: May 11, 2008 09:53

Rose Batignani

So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. This article speaks to everyone! I always have had a fear of public speaking and I hate to be critiqued, especially in front of a large group of people. As a designer, we need to understand that these critiques will help us in the long run. No one is perfect and sometimes your design is not speaking to your target audience. Large corporations spend thousands of dollars for valuable client feed back regarding new products and designs. Everyone must remember when they are presenting to the class to accept the students responses as advice and don’t let our ego shut them out. They are here to help you.

Reply
Posted: May 11, 2008 14:41

Ann OKeeffe

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind." It's vital to remember that as a graphic designer, you are doing work for someone else. Your assignment is for the benefit of another party, your client. Not all eyes see the same thing, but it is your client's perception that is important.

Reply
Posted: May 11, 2008 22:11

Lyska. Vanté

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. To get defensive is counterproductive" Truth be told through these lines!! You can only learn more to please a future audience when a present one gives you their opinions and criticism. Its a jungle out in the buisness life, filled with competition and hardship. To become the best.. open your mind to what others think best! Know that there is always something to learn and you'll find yourself to be shaped into creating things beyond a selfish mind.

Reply
Posted: May 12, 2008 18:05

Laurie L Thomas

(I know this is the first line but) "We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style. One of the things that I struggled with especially when I first began classes at Valencia was getting defensive or taking comments about my projects too personally." This reminds me of one thing I hate in all art communities, saying that its your 'style' when really, you just don't want to learn. Deviant Art is promiscuous with this. Don't take comments personally but do take the time to evaluate it and see if you understand where the person is coming from (or if they really are just being negative)

Reply
Posted: May 13, 2008 08:51

Melissa Provenzano

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." I will definitely take this advice and keep this in the back of my mind during critiques. I really believe that I will be able to take the criticism and remind myself that it's being said so that I can improve. We, as people, usually can't see our own flaws, so it's good that people can point them out so we know what needs to be worked on. I will really work on not taking anything personal.

Reply
Posted: May 13, 2008 09:51

Michelle Ledesma

"For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous. I have a fear of public speaking." i can relate to this i don't like talk in front of people sometimes but it has to be done so i can get over that fear and its good the see what others have to say sometime causes it can help you come up with better things or fix what you have and make it better

Reply
Posted: May 13, 2008 16:33

Audrey Bay

"This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track." I too am dreading the critique portion of these courses, but understand that if I plan on going into this profession, every single piece I ever design will eventually be critiqued. I'm more nervous about explaining my ideas than I am at being critiqued. As long as it in constructive, I hope to embrace it. As Kristy stated, your criticisms could be exactly what you need to keep your project on track and headed in the right direction.

Reply
Posted: May 13, 2008 23:06

Jen Hubert

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work." Of course we all get defensive about our work especially when we work really hard on it to impress the teacher and students in the class. Everyone has their own styles, opinions, and ways they think about things. Maybe if someone did not understand my work I would probably present it in another way that they might understand better. I actually like the good and bad comments given to me, I get to see both strengths and weaknesses. It drives me to do better next time.

Reply
Posted: May 14, 2008 00:31

Doris Rosado

after I had worked on something for hours and days, I had to put my project on the board in front of everyone.” sometimes this can be one of the hardest part of a project because we have to receptacle to others point of views and ideas on how to better ones project which isn't always isnt easy to listen after several hours of hard work

Reply
Posted: May 14, 2008 06:22

Javon Johnson

" Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work" I choose particular excerpt because I live it everyday at work. As a programmer, I try to coach and help other programmers to be more diverse and have more depth, but this can easily be mistaken for something else. Constructive criticism is the key in helping you to" broader your horizon"

Reply
Posted: May 14, 2008 13:13

Harold Ramos

Let’s face it we all have egos. We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style. If and artist does not have a large ego or great expectation of him/herself then new creative thoughts would not be explored. Creating new things is what drives all artist and a large ego is needed to survive in this industry.

Reply
Posted: May 14, 2008 14:12

Jon Manock

So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. Not everybody is going to see the vision that you see, there are a lot of bosses and ceo's that are to attached to the old ways. But they are the ones paying you!

Reply
Posted: May 14, 2008 15:04

Andrea Keller

“learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind” I am torn about these critiques. On the one hand I too have a fear of public speaking especially when comments could be negative. I tend to put my emotions into everything I do and take things too personally. On the other hand, I truly value others opinions especially if the project has been difficult and their added insight might be just the thing to get my mind on the right track. I am going to try to take her advice and “learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind” and remember that different eyes see different things and to keep in mind who’s count…the client’s!

Reply
Posted: May 14, 2008 17:04

Nicholas Miller

" I had to put my project on the board in front of everyone. Then I had to explain my ideas and listen to feedback offered by my fellow graphic design students. " I understand the author’s situation and also what she had to go through. I myself had problems with public speaking, it always made me nervous. Getting ones work viewed and critiqued is definitely a part of the world of graphic design. Though, it is better to face it now while we are in school than to wait until we get into the career world. This way we get used to it now. Also based on the responses we get from the people that judge our work we can better our work while we are in college. We will be better prepared once we get into the work force that way.

Reply
Posted: May 15, 2008 00:17

Diego Dutra

“When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind.” The class can have very advanced people and people with just other mind set goals. Whenever I receive feedback on any work I take it into mind always wanted to reward or fix my errors. Good point.

Reply
Posted: May 15, 2008 00:20

Christina Flynn

“Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." This is very true and everyone should take to make their work better, but no personal. Yes it can be personally but I know that I am thankful when ever I receive constructive criticism.

Reply
Posted: May 15, 2008 00:54

Brittany Teunis

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." You cannot get ahead without the opinion of others, just like you can't without practice. Construction criticism is one of the keys to building your artistic eye and the level of your work.

Reply
Posted: May 15, 2008 08:32

Koisha B.

"This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track." I agree with this statement because often times we think more of the long hours we spent working on the project instead of thinking what can be improved, in order for our projects to be top notch we must accept that different points of view may be better than one .

Reply
Posted: May 19, 2008 16:29

Jennifer Johnson

Wow! I'm glad that my article was something that others could relate to. It get's easier as time goes on. Just keep that in mind. I even am a lot less fearful of explaining my work in front of others since critique is such an important part of classes at Valencia. I have done some portfolio reviews this year and just going through the critique process made me more prepared to explain my work to professionals that are actually working out on the field right now. Good luck to everyone! :-)

Reply
Posted: August 28, 2008 12:16

Angela Kreye

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work." it's important to always keep in mind that most critiques are designed to help you improve. I try to keep this in mind whenever I ask for someone's opinion. I cannot completely separate my emotions from my work but it's something I try to work at with every critique I receive.

Reply
Posted: August 28, 2008 22:10

John Pascual

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. " You have to listen to what other people have to say because they may be right. The truth sometimes hurts, so put an ice pack on it and move on. Maybe if you add that one little piece of advice to your work, it may turn out to be the missing piece. It could turn out to be your masterpiece.

Reply
Posted: August 29, 2008 08:00

Sandra Bryan

So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. Feedback, given in a positive or negative way, is always welcome to further your development. I would appreciate being told if my project is good or bad. Be honest. I don't want to waste my time, or the instructors, if I'm going down the wrong path.

Reply
Posted: August 29, 2008 15:29

Mark Prather

"After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." I have a problem with critiques usually as well with people telling me whether or not they like the piece. Which in my mind it's awesome if you like it or not but more importantly Why, I'm not gonna learn what to fix or what to keep if you don't communicate. So for those of us with tougher skin tell me it sucks cause as the artist I'm only gonna see the mistakes that I know are there. not the ones I don't .

Reply
Posted: August 30, 2008 22:01

Marie Alicea

"learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. " Part of life is listening to other people's comments and critiques. I haven't gone through the critique parts in these classes yet and it makes me nervous a little, but I will do the same I've always known; take in the good and reject the bad.

Reply
Posted: August 31, 2008 18:33

Elyssa Coultas

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." Showing my design to my peers is something I'm definitely not looking forward to because I hate public speaking. Plus, it's even more nervewracking because it's something artistic that you designed and created. But she is completely right, being critiqued is what will make every student grow as a designer, and as a person. We should all humbly take criticism and use it for improvement of future projects.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 11:49

Leslie Bilger

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work. " It is the same for me. I have the chance to spend two years in an Art School were I had to present my works everyday to a lot of teachers and students (I have to say they were really mean!). At first it was really hard. When you hear some violent critics about what you made and that you have spend hours and days on this project it makes you really angry and sad. But with the time you learn that when you'll work you'll find some people who will behave the same. You learn how not to loose your temper and use those critics to be better.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 12:10

Kathrine Fleming

"When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." I know this is something I will continually strive to improve. I realize I have a lot to learn in order to say be proficient in graphic design. One of my goals is to become Great and feedback is one of the keys to becoming better which will aid in leading me toward designs that are great.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 13:46

Jihad Canaan

Criticism is probably one of the hardest steps in the whole design process. It is really frustrating to hear someone give you negative criticism on something you spent hours, days, even weeks working on. I also get very defensive when it comes to something I have created, it's natural to do so. So even the most negative of criticisms can be seen as positive, because there is always room for improvement, so don't take it personally, take it as an opportunity to grow.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 15:36

Caspar Blattmann

“One of the things that I struggled with especially when I first began classes at Valencia was getting defensive or taking comments about my projects too personally.” I have a tendency to get defensive myself. And it is easy to take critic personally, especially when we think of our designs as a stroke of genius and see those who criticize us as not being able to see what we see. This is a hurdle we need to overcome since clients will criticize us and expect us to take it and respond to it in a professional way. Critique can also help us to think about a design in a new way and possibly spawn new creativity. Ever since I started doing some design work, I have gotten better in taking criticism. It is not about me.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 17:06

Wilkins Delgado

We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style. It's because of this that i find it hard to criticize other peoples work. I find most things amazing because they did what came out of there head and their ideas and all though it may be different from what i would have done its unique and that's awesome.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 19:54

Lusk, Michael

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work." As designers and members of the creative service industry we need to keep more open minded and be flexable with our understanding that no ones opinion is really wrong. It just a different persective, that's it.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 20:38

Katie Schrader

"This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track." Criticism is something that should be taken in, listened to, and then judged. Constructive criticism can help you grow as an artist, and it allows you to improve your ideas. Unfortunately, not all criticism is constructive or accurate, and that is why one has to judge what has been said and then decide whether to heed the advice or to discard it. Creativity is a wonderful thing that takes different form in every project; not everyone is alike and not everyone will like the same things. This is why I love art, if everyone liked and created the same things how boring would that be! Listen to the advice given and then decide if the suggestions will improve your designs or if the criticism merely comes because of a different opinion in style. Distinguishing between the two different types of criticism will allow you to become a better artist but still maintain your own individual style.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 23:25

Eliud Acosta

'Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind.' This is so true. You have to be open to criticism without taking it personally. Well, really it has to be constructive, not just any type of criticism is acceptable. I am always open to constructive criticism because I know that im given advice on how to improve my work and all i ever want to do is get better at what I do. Sometimes something may look right to me but another person may actually give me a better idea of how to imiprove my idea. Instead of thinking that they just did not like my work, or were possibly jealous of my work, I try to see it through the other person's perspective. In this case, it could be my teacher or a fellow classmate. Really, all they are doing is helping me better my work.

Reply
Posted: September 1, 2008 23:37

Michael Canning

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." That's a very great point. However, handling criticism is easier said than done. Naturally when someone may not like your work, and calls you out on it, you want to defend yourself and your work. However, people just want to help you make your work and skills better. So handling criticism is a must, if you want to better improve yourself. Although I still haven't master this concept yet, I still try to deal with criticism, so for people who have a problem with this, just remember not to take it personally.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 02:14

Carlos Alvarado

"This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track." Very true. I've never been in a class that required critiques but I would always hear from friends that did and would always get the "I hate critiques" comment right away. I know I don't have any experiences with critiques but I've always seen them as a beneficial process to the designer. Its not so much people saying your work is bad, more as people helping you see what you could have done better.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 10:30

Halie Coberley

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. I choose this quote because constructive criticism is what i base my work around. I love when people tell me things i could have done better or something they didnt like in order for me to relate with others through my work. This work as a whole is a great eye opener to the people who hate it when there work is being criticized. aka dont take it personally!!! a great title!

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 11:16

John Molina

When it comes to creating something that is not meant to be for personal use, I try to make it as clear as possible so it conveys whatever message that needs to be out there. There will always be someone who does not like what you do or just cannot come to an agreement to what you have created. Taking critiques in my eyes would only help me expand my creativity because that way an idea that is given for one project could be used in another, and just like anything else you for the most part want and need an outsiders view on what you are doing to make sure it is something that spreads like wildfire.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 11:19

Duan Molina

"-learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." I feel this is an important quote to always keep in mind. Graphic design is about communicating an idea, and if your audience doesn't respond the way you intended you need to be able to adjust your idea and ultimately satisfy the client/audience.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 11:51

Stefanie Franchi

I don't have much experience with critiquing, but i Know I don't do well with public speaking in front of a class. I tend to get very nervous as well.I 'v been wondering how i should go about critiquing and being critiqued. I now have a better Idea of what it might be like or how to go about it after reading this blog article.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 13:59

Leisha Ramirez

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind" -This is exactly what I need to work on. In class presentations and accepting feedback. Its true, getting feedback from other students, could be a good thing no matter if the feedback is good or bad. The problem is going to present your work after someone that has done an extraordinary job. This makes me feel lousy. Guess I got to work on my competitive side too because there's always going to be someone better. *tear

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 14:50

David Remedios

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work" -Struggling with a project is rough but it's even more rough once you have to present that idea to other students.No matter how rough it may be I agree that it's best to detach yourself from your assignment emotionally and think about what is best for you as a designer.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 15:29

Amy Kelso

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." I think learning to accept constructive criticism is very crucial to doing well in this field. Everyone interprets art differently, so not getting defensive about what you may find to be artistically appealing maybe a tough pill to swallow. But with that being said, it opens up the notion that someone cares that much about something you worked so diligently on to try to help you improve on it. And in all honesty, if you receive tough criticism it should want to make you work that much harder to make the end result something that will make people speechless.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 15:53

Angel Martinez

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind. This will be the most hardest task for me as a designer because I am hard headed when it comes to taking someone elses open on my work I will have to practice on this just like everything else in this field to become a better designer

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 16:49

DaRosa Sandra

So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication. Why and reaction is! Most people probably feel the same way, or even might get defensive. But I usually take is as I'm not going to quite, I'll try to show the persons that I can do it better, and usually try a lot harder.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 18:31

Melissa Cheng

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. This is a very good way to improve on your work or projects especially when you're open to all the criticism coming towards you. However if you tend to take all the criticism too personally, you won't see an improvement in your work; instead your quality and confidence in your work will decrease.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 20:13

Lee Drake

"Let’s face it we all have egos." I found this line intriguing because it is true, but in a field like graphics design people need to learn to take constructive criticism because it can help them in the long run.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 21:08

Thomas Peña

"Let’s face it we all have egos. We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style." Oh yeah, its nerve breaking to spend so much time on something and then be told that its missing something or that its not quite right, but you have to get past that and accept it.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 23:16

Qianli Ma

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." This sentence is the key of the article. I know how hard it is to take any criticism from clients or coworker. But a graphic designer has to do the job. He not only put the a piece of work in front of others, but also explains what concept is. That is the most important step to go for client or whoever may be interesting to understand the work that you have been made. The masterpieces have been criticized by centuries, and they are still perfectly good. As a conclusion, communication is very important between graphic designers and clients, the proper criticism is absolutely fine.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 23:21

Tiffany Jensen

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." This is the ONLY thing that I know I will have to get over. I am so shy when it comes to anything creative that I do. I can't take constructive criticism without getting hurt, even though I know it's for my own good. I know that my professors and fellow classmates are not saying anything to be intentionally hurtful or mean, but I'm very sensitive and as hard as I try to be appreciative, I always end up getting defensive. That's the biggest thing I know I will have to conquer in this program. I know that I cannot go into the design world being as sensitive as I am. I know that I will have a client that doesn't like what I do initially. I know that I will have to take the criticism with an open mind, and actually listen in order to produce the desired result. This article is a great way to remind myself that it's for my own good.

Reply
Posted: September 2, 2008 23:54

Mike Lucarelli

Let’s face it we all have egos. Most artists have big egos, thinking that they shouldn't have to change their ideas for someones critique. I'm guilty of that. I'll have to learn to take it as constructive criticism and use it to make my works better, because a client is going to want it how they want it.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 00:30

Jonathan Tenjo

When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind. Appropriately respond to evaluations or critique comments in a non-defensive and non-argumentative way.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 02:18

Alex Bennett

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." Great minds are sharpened by one another. "As iron sharpens iron, so one man sharpens another." It's important to embrace the opportunity of this sharpening that is offered in the classes we are enrolled in. I mean honestly, its harmless. Right?

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 02:22

Joleen A. Yarnell

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work" I agree. Keeping an open mind and ear for constructive criticism is important for improvement. There have been plenty of times when someone would mention a change I could do to a project to make it better; instead of dismissing them, I take it into consideration and my work is better for it.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 08:23

Kristi Foreman

This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track. Very true, we must accept others thoughts on our work and then bring together all that feedback to better define and modify our work. By listening to others we will be able to refine and judge our work in relation to its context in the outside world.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 10:15

Doug Wise

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." The reason I highlight this point is because it's one of the fundamental stages in any design process. If graphic design had a locker room, this would be one of the quotes on the wall. As I said before in recent responses to various posts, graphic design is as much about listening to others than it is about listening to yourself. Certainly, it's important to understand your own design processes and influences, but at the end of the day are you creating this design for yourself or for other people to enjoy or look at? If you're making a living in graphic design chances are you're creating things for other people. That doesn't mean you can't be true to yourself, but it's important to make your design process collaborative. And that involves taking constructive criticism.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 10:38

Soeh Cotto

When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind. It's difficult not to take things personally specially when you put a lot of work and hours to a project and then someone gives you a bad comment. Since this is my first semester taking design classes it will be difficult but I will try to keep an open mind when people give me advise on my work because I know that I need it.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 10:44

Julia Hawkins

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." I used to take negative criticism personally, but I've learned that I need to keep an open mind to new ideas. Criticism is a good thing. It's good to look at things from a different perspective.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 10:45

Yessenia Lantigua

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." I've already taken a class or two that has involved constructive criticism and I'll admit it's not always my favorite part. Though it's not my favorite thing, I know it is a necessity. My point of view will differ from others and in design your work should be appealing to more then just one person, (yourself.) One would be surprised with the amount of positive input you'll receive from your fellow classmates. It's all about having confidence in your work but still being open to others opinions.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 10:58

Fernando Murrugarra

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a way that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work." That is something we all have to deal with in our career. The thought of having all your hard work criticized by so many people makes one believe that it was all worth nothing. However, these critiques help to improve your work and truly see what went wrong and how you can change it. Life doesn't require perfection. It takes one step at a time.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 10:59

Lee Waters

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." Learning to do this is tough at first, I agree, but now I look forward to critiques on my projects. Not only do they give you advice but its good to step back and look at the project yourself, sometimes after looking at every detail for so long and up close you miss the big picture. Its also good to see what other people think and how they perceive it.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:04

Paige Allen

"We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style." I completely agree with this exerpt. Creativity comes from within, whether we are truly artistic by nature, or we are just willing to others in life. Everyone is creative in their own special way. They just have a different way of showing it. Life is weird some times and people are harder to understand than others. We are all special each others eyes; we may not show it in time, but deeply we are very unique and creative in different ways in life. That is why we choose jobs that helps us become a more socialable person or even to create ways of attracting friends and other people to our lives.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:18

Chel-C Moody

"For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous. I have a fear of public speaking. Additionally that fear is increased when I think others might not like my work." I think everyone gets nervous when they know their work is about to get critiqued by people around the same age as themselves. But i guess thats just college and life, how are you gonna get really good at what you love if you cant fix your problems that other people can help you fix.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:22

Nick Shirley

" Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." I also had a problem getting in front of the class and being criticized on my work. But now I take the criticism a lot better because now it motivates me and inspires me to work harder and make my designs better. It also gives me an idea of what people like, so I could add more of it to my work to make it more appealing.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:24

"L" Rosa

“We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style.” *claps hands* It's all about our own artistic identity when presenting a concept in our own unique style. It's all part of the creative process. Like I had stated in another response, without it, life would be dull and depressing. It's our job to put these concepts in ways that people can appreciate them in their own way

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:26

"L" Rosa

“We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style.” *claps hands* It’s all about our own artistic identity when presenting a concept in our own unique style. It’s all part of the creative process. Like I had stated in another response, without it, life would be dull and depressing. It’s our job to put these concepts in ways that people can appreciate them in their own way

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:31

jonathan kidwell

I agree with Julia Hawkins, being constructive is the key to improving ones art work.understanding that we are only human and we can all use others ideas or thoughts just to make sure you are still appealing to your market audience.so keep an open mind and understand you my not like the response you may receive. I for one have had teachers,students and family examine my art work and at times there was nothing held back, they flat out criticized the work and offered me no advice or comments that highlighted things i did correctly. so my advice be ready for hate and learn from mistakes.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 11:39

Jasper Stephens

"Let’s face it we all have egos." This is true to most of the people of the world, but something their is nothing wrong with a little ego boost. Might give you more confidence to do more work. Just avoid get a over huge ego that leads a person to act smug. Just a little bit at a time should help.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 12:10

Dave Dorbat

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind." Best advice any graphic designer could ever take. Especially earlier in your career. This industry really is about pleasing other people; thus when it comes down to it you have to be ready to hear people out about what their view of something is.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 13:51

Caitlin Elmore

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind." This is a positive article that explained a lot and gave a lot of advice that I really need to take in to be a graphic designer, especially when being critiqued on a project I've done. I know when people critique my work, that it's nothing personal, and it's just something I should just learn to accept and have an open mind about. In the end, with other people's suggestions and ideas, my work can get better. This article will help other students as well as myself understand the reason as to why we critique each other's work.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 14:23

Lindsey Rowe

“When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind.” I will keep to this because I am looking to that person a potential costumer. I must also think about where there coming from, and why they don’t like it. All criticism should be used for learning about a client of that background.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 14:26

Viviana Castano

"When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." I chose this line because it is something we need to learn and not forget. Yes, at times we will, I know I do but I have made a point to myself when offered advice, ideas, or critiques to ask that person to explain their ideas, critiques, etc if I don't see or understand what that person is saying so I can learn and understand why.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 14:35

Diane Zeise

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. " I think I'm really good at being my own worst critic, but when it comes to others opinions, I know I'm not open minded. I get defensive with my work because I know how hard I've worked on it. It's relieving to read that someone struggles with the same obstacles I do.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 14:50

Jennifer Grullon

"For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous." I have gotten up in front of groups so many times but every single time i feel dreaded nerves and although i may sound regular my heart beats 100 times per second and i feel like i'm about to die! This stood out because i know now that i am going to be dealing with this on a consistant basis at VCC especially when we design something. I need to become comfortable with this if i plan to succeed and be better. Although i am not looking forward to it!!!

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 15:10

Alice Schumann

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." I agree with this statement. Communication is the key to successful projects. Sometimes it can be easy to let out personal feelings get involved, this can either be negative or positive.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 15:16

Erica Wheaton

"It’s a good skill to develop a familiarity with, since it will be necessary when we are out working in the real world. I still get nervous though!" I couldn't agree more! I am very comfortable with public speaking and receiving critiques, but I still get nervous at times too. I was constantly giving presentations to potential clients and giving speeches at city council and county commissioner meetings at my most recent job. I came to realize that if you at least LOOK like you know what you're talking about, then you're set. You can never give anyone a reason to panic and don't show your mistakes.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 15:23

Erica Carrero

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." Im pretty good at taking a step back and looking at my project and judging my own work as if I were seeing through someone elses eyes but I agree that it is important to keep an open mind when someone else does critique my work. Part of me may still feel the need to be defensive at times when the work that I slaved over for hours and hours isnt what the audience wants to see or isnt communicating the message properly, but I know that if I show something I thought was good, and it turned out to be something people thought wasnt as good as I thought, It only makes me better in the end!

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 15:59

Kristin Murphy

Constructive criticism helps the designer realize whether or not they are getting the correct idea across to the viewer. If someone is making suggestions, it is probably because they are confused about the message of the piece or they feel that you can add something to portray it better

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 16:19

Ashley Atkins

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." This is really good advice! When your classmates give you constructive criticism, it's just that, constructive! They wouldn't say anything at all if they didn't want to help. I took a Design class last semester, and instead of getting defensive I would lose confidence in my work, until I realized I was saying the same things to other students during presentations. And it wasn't to be mean or to offend them, but to help them and make suggestions.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 16:21

Cynthia Baptiste

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." This is very true. If someone is not willing to listen, they cannot hear and the end result is that none of the necessary changes are made. I think that there is a second step to this though. We can't just be willing to listen to constructive critique, but we need to appreciate it, seek it, and apply it so that we achieve maximum potential. It is very helpful to practice listening to critique while at school, because in the design world, a client has the right to tell the designer what his/her vision is and how he/she would like to presentation modified. So the sooner we the design students learns to accept critique, the better prepared we can be for the real [design] world.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 17:05

Jeff Haughey

So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. This advice doesn't just apply for graphic designers, but for every occupation. Chances are you are not a prodigy and already know everything there is to know. This is where feedback and communication come into play. People are going to comment on what you do and it's wise to listen to what they have to say. It's all about constructive criticism. Everthing can be done better, most of the time, so take the feedback and try to improve. Don't let emotions get involved because this will only hinder you.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 17:08

Jonathan Pierce

"learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." I don't know how I would be if someone was negative about my work. But I think that if someone had a good point I would be able to take that advice. Especially if the teacher agrees with them.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 17:37

Braxton Burabge

I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work. This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track. So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication. people all have different personalities and we all have different phobias. if you can concur your fear then anything can be accomplished with some dedication.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 19:13

Amanda Chambers

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." I chose this excerpt because it is something I also have trouble with. I get really nervous when anyone is looking at my artwork. I don't want to hear anything negative. Although I know that it is a necessary evil and it will pay off it in the end, it's just not my favorite part.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 19:57

Kayla Hernandez

" I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work." I can totally relate to this feeling, I try to defend my mind set when really I should be absorbing the observation of others, sometimes it helps to have someone else's eyes

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 20:04

Aaron Thompson

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. I believe very much because I appreciate when my teachers and peers talk about my work and how to improve it

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 20:15

Desiree Pirela

I fear being in front of everybody just trying to explain my work, but I think that I can get use to it by practicing; of course it is going to be frustrating the first times. The main motive is the desire of being better everyday and yes, being "open mind" to the critics of people about my projects. At the end the comments are always to improve or give new ideas to the work.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 20:40

camilo avila

"For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous. I have a fear of public speaking". I chose this excerpt because it is clear that I have a fear for public speaking.YESS! it is reallly hard for me.I tend to miss pronounce words because I get really nervous.but yeahhh at the end I think its not that bad and this semester Im willing to deal with this and overcome it.the first couple of times will be hard but I will eventually get used to it. all I need is some practice and to not be afraid to express my ideas infront of everyone.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 20:47

Nate Valdez

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. I swear you never believe it at first but it's actually the truth! I already accept that not everyone will like my work but at the end of the day the client's thoughts are the only person's i care to hear. If they like what I do great, next assignment will be even better. If they don't like, fine I'll correct what they don't like and make sure that the next assignment I'm given blows the client's expectations out of the water! Either way its a win-win for me (it doesn't feel like it when I'm hearing the criticism but it really is) Don't Take It Personally is probably the best way to survive this industry, plain and simple

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 20:53

thomas huynh

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind." I believe with an open mind your work can have a lot more diversity.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 21:00

Edith Oquendo

"Let’s face it we all have egos." Of course we all have egos, and they are HUGE!!! However, we should never let our egos take over. Egos are made to protect us, but many times our egos blinds us and create a false sense of reality, we become selfish. However, I believe if we keep our egos to ourselves, we let shine thru our true creative self, we become less intimidating to others an we become someone everybody wants to hang out with and in the end a better professional that anyone will hire in a heart beat.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 22:03

Eric Montalvo

"Let’s face it we all have egos. We are creatives and we spend our time coming up with concepts that we then try to present in our own interesting way and style." Everyone has egos, its just that we cant be too personal with our work or else it can bring serious problems.

Reply
Posted: September 3, 2008 22:15

Dylan Kane

"...my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind." Not only is it a good plan to keep an open mind. But the feedback you receive should be taken into consideration. Getting critiqued in class will better your experience with business deals and clients if you land a job in the industry. Positive attitude is the only way to go. Just like the article name itself...DON'T TAKE IT PERSONALLY!

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 00:39

Steven Conrado

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." This is the most honest and truthful article I read tonight. This part of class is going to be the hardest for me. I am not looking forward being in front of class, having students criticizing my work but this is something I have to get us to, not only because of the industry we are going into, but this is the best way to improve as a designer.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 03:24

Lori Paschal

"For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous." Even the most experienced speakers and performers get nervous in front of groups. I think it's general human nature. We'd rather be part of the mob than faced with any mob, angry or not. The key is to keep the detached attitude and avoid paranoia. They're not all out to get you after all.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 08:21

Simien Antonis-Parr

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." I do tend to struggle with accepting constructive criticism. I don't think that it is my ego that is the block but just a small case of doubt. There is usually a pattern when a critique happens. People critique, I doubt, go home, think, then correct piece, and move on. Each time I get a little better. And it's only in my nature to make mistakes. Also, the times I accept the criticism is when I have a masterpiece in the end.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 12:14

Cyndi Boggs

"This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track." OK we are in the graphic design career path. If no one understand what we are trying to communicate then we have failed. I think this statement is true for alot of us because we take it as attacks on us personally. Well we are just gonna have to accept it and process the criticism and make it better and help express what we are trying to say. It can only make our work better.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 12:18

Lisa Lauttenbach

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." Sure it sucks sometimes but constructive criticism really helps me improve my work. I like when people point out things I may have missed whether it be a mistake or something that really stands out in a way I hadn't really intended.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 12:30

Jocelyn Law

I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work. i think this will be my biggest problem. some times i get defensive if someone critizes me or my work in a negative way. i have to learn how to get over that.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 14:43

kristin budesa

“Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind.” This is something I often need to remind myself of – the fact there’s a difference between criticism and constructive criticism and that when someone offers ‘advice or ideas on something that we have created’, it’s important to take all those thoughts and suggestions into consideration and remember that getting an outside opinion is helpful more often than not.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 15:26

Stephen Carey

Criticism is always hard to take if interpreted incorrectly. Keep an open mind, whether your work is on the chopping block, or your expressing your opinion about a fellow peer. I have had problems with keep an open mind and try to not take what others think so personally. Majority of the comments about your art work is just to better and make it more appealing to everyone and not just you.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 16:51

kevin Mccrystal

I have a fear of public speaking. Additionally that fear is increased when I think others might not like my work. I used this excerpt because it reminds me of how nervous i get when I get in front of people. funny thing is I use to teach karate classes all by myself and had no problem. My reaction to this excerpt was to find a way not to be so nervous.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 16:55

Plinio Tejeda

It’s a good skill to develop a familiarity with, since it will be necessary when we are out working in the real world. As a designer we all know that the work we do must be shown to someone else. This is beneficial in a way which can improve your work or give you new fresh ideas about a future project. I myself am afraid to speak in public specially large groups, but as we all know it is a fear that we all have to overpass.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 17:10

Alison Toro

Additionally that fear is increased when I think others might not like my work. I know the feeling. Its normally when I'm not prepared. When i feel like i could have done more and i have a flat graphic with different shapes and the person next to me recreated an entire field of butterflies. Some people have a different way of looking at things. I prefer bold while others prefer pretty.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 17:24

Jade Lawhon

“learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind” I could eat feedback for breakfast lunch and dinner. It's true that sometimes, I'll hear the worst of a critic, and I have two choices smile and think of the carious thing it "could" of meant, or get defensive. One of these choices get me NO where. I've learned I need to take in whatever advice is given even if I feel that it might not pertain to me. Thankfully I feel open to what ever shoots me down, or brings me up. it's good to build that, a closed mind will get you no where.

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 18:04

Linda Poiesz

"I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work." I hate to have people see my weaknesses, even though weaknesses are completely human. I try to do my best at most times, and for someone to see that I'm not always good is embarrassing. I understand that not everyone excels at everything, but sometimes you spend so much time on a prject that you become attached. But as long as the criticism is constructive and not mean-spirited, I will just have to get over that hang-up!

Reply
Posted: September 4, 2008 18:19

Thanpisith Chanakul

"So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." Ay, communication, one of Valencia's "core ideas." Communication is key to having success in a work field involving many different types of people. In addition, receiving feedback on your work isn't so bad; now you know you have room for improvement.

Reply
Posted: September 7, 2008 00:45

JOEY WERNER aka JOS.A

Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work. When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind. I think that of course we should keep an open mind always, regarding everything, not just design. However I think if you are good, and you know your good(which I am in no way claiming of myself!) then I think you can kind of shrug off some suggestions. There comes a time when hopefully your design and art skills have combined with your natural artistic talents, and all those programs we love so much to create you, and your style. I like to think that if your true to your style (once its been developed), and if you believe your work rocks, then let anyone who doesn't like it look at something else. So many times people especially in arts, and entertainment business didn't get their first, second, or thirtieth job because they wouldn't compromise their art/design/music/acting etc. But then came along the 31'st job and all of the sudden there the biggest thing since sliced bread. Be true to yourself!

Reply
Posted: September 7, 2008 17:30

Steven Yu

“For me getting in front of any group is tough because it makes me really nervous. I have a fear of public speaking. Additionally that fear is increased when I think others might not like my work" I have a horrible fear of public speaking and being in the spot light. I put alot of hard thought and work into my art and designs. That really doesnt help much, but I am trying to get out of that rut because I know that public speaking is a top priority

Reply
Posted: September 7, 2008 20:32

Keren Kuilan

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." I chose this excerpt because having finished a degree in Fine Arts I couldn't agree more with this statement. Critiques are an integral part in every course, so you have to get used to people not always liking your work. But once you can get past all that, constructive criticism can allow you to see things through other peoples eyes. It's another tool to help you fine tune your creative design so that your vision can become theirs as well.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 01:39

Freddy Debord

"When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind." I really appreciate this line because, at my current job, feedback is so highly encouraged. I will admit that it took some time to see how it was helping and there are colleagues who have a better approach to it than others. But now I can honestly say that all types of criticism is highly appreciated because it always helps even when it hurts. It kind of reminds me of those stories about performers who appear on amateur night at the Apollo Theatre in New York. If it makes you angry, try to use it as a source of motivation to succeed with whatever you're working to become or create. Just remember: it's business, never personal.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 11:19

Julia Miller

"After all we all have the same goal, which is communication." This line is important to keep in mind because as artists and designers communinication is essentially what we must aim for. Art is a way to speak our thoughts and ideas through what we create rather than through our words, so maintaining efficient communication to others is important. Negative criticism will arise and I know that even if it is difficult to hear it is without a doubt helpful. If others have negative things to say about my work it could be that the message I am trying to communicate is not clear in my work so I know that if I want to be a good artist and designer I should handle criticism well and use the reaction of critics to furthermore improve my work and my ability to speak through it.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 11:57

Jonathan DuFault

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." I couldn't have said it better myself. I too have had my fair share of class critiques and I can admit that it is difficult to sometimes hear that someone doesn't like or understand your work. It can be frustrating, especially if you put a lot of time into it. But, constructive criticism is a huge part of growing as an artist and I'm glad that I have learned to except it in a positive way.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 13:33

Daniel Canepa

“Let’s face it we all have egos” Everyone with talent has egos. This is very true, because I have many… an example is like the article said, because I would also love for my talents to take me places. I would want to be famous, but then again I am very shy and I hate public speaking, I would love to be recognized but I hate it when people give me praise. Weird huh, so I pretty much would react the same way and not try to take many things too personally.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 17:30

DrewWoerner

"embrace feedback and keep an open mind" we can all accept feedback, but embracing it and actually utilizing it is the chore

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 18:16

Rachael Truex

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." Constructive criticism can make your art work even better then it was. Getting defensive over a point of view isn't worth it. Just go with the flow, and be open minded with other people's point of views.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 20:40

Nestor Vera

When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind. I think Perspective is something of extreme importance not only in design but in many aspects of our lives, and in many occasion we will find ourselves stuck with one idea or not being able to see something else, I believe to listen to someone else opinion is very important, they might give us a completely new perspective that can take us to a different path and to make a better work.

Reply
Posted: September 8, 2008 20:54

Shauna Vatovec

learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. Keeping an open mind has luckily been something I am able to portray. My artwork drawings and websites have always been critisized and I've almost built a wall against it. Constructive critism on a peice will only better that peice and besides who wouldn't want 30 different opinions?

Reply
Posted: September 9, 2008 00:01

Lencia Marc

When someone offers advice or ideas on something that we have created we should keep an open mind. I am the kind of person who takes every advice that is addressed to me personally. This sentence reminds me to keep an open mind when I do get feedback on my work.

Reply
Posted: September 9, 2008 08:22

Caitlin Dundey

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." i couldnt' agree with this more. Contructive critisim can help you in the best ways possible, and such example is giving you different ideas that you woulnd't normally consider yourself, that can help take your design to the next step.

Reply
Posted: September 9, 2008 09:05

Mark Boulier

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." This is such an important thing to remember that I believe so many forget time and time again. I have seen people in other classes take critiques way to personal.

Reply
Posted: January 20, 2009 16:55

Sean Irvin

"I have a tendency to get defensive about my work. This is counterproductive" While I sometimes do get offended when something I thought was a clear message falls on deaf ears I have to quickly remind myself the only to get better is to hear where you need to get better. If everyone liked everything I ever did then I either have peaked way to early or am surrounded by liars. I hope neither is true and therefore welcome critique when it is offered.

Reply
Posted: January 20, 2009 23:04

Jason Byrd

"Fear is increased when I think others might not like my work." I choose this for the fact that we all go through the same fear at some point of our lives. Most have experience facing this fear at an early age then you have those like me who had to really work hard at getting the nerve just to express my mind in front of more then one person, myself. I do like the one-on-one interaction between two people, but have struggled with large numbers. This might be the reason I didn't choose public speaking as my major. My voice is my art, so I thought. Now, more then ever, to get my art in the hands of others, I must use my voice and except their comments with a grain of salt.

Reply
Posted: January 21, 2009 01:24

Hunter Nagler

It's one of the worst fear's to have in life. An inability to take risks for fear of consequence on a mental level is incredibly hurtful to a creative process. Everyone has different views and ideas and opinions, so there's bound to be disagreements as to which is the best course of action to achieve a particular goal. It was put best for me a long time ago, though, the truth of the matter. When you have great ideas fighting for the collective goal of being the best, there isn't a best, or even a better. No better, no worse, just different. Different way's of achieving the same goal, and in the end that's what matters. Hitting your deadlines and achieving your goals. You can argue who had the better idea over cocktails at the after-parties 8-)

Reply
Posted: January 21, 2009 14:25

Herbart Ruiz

"learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind." I felt the same way in the past, where I have been apprehensive about having my work criticized. However, I find it to be the best way to improve on the creative process. Two or more minds are better than one. I think of it this way, my clients will do the same. I will take that input and apply it to best suit their needs.

Reply
Posted: January 24, 2009 19:13

Matt Volodzko

So my advice to anyone looking to become a graphic designer, learn to embrace feedback and keep an open mind. I have to keep this in MY mind. I will probably think my work sucks anyway and taking feedback will make me feel worse, but it is a good thing, not bad.

Reply
Posted: January 26, 2009 14:20

Rosalba Maldonado

"fear is increased when I think others might not like my work. " No-one likes to be criticised, but when we’re a designer is part of life. If clients are paying for our design, then they will feel free to tell you so. Breath deeply and take it with a smile!

Reply
Posted: January 26, 2009 16:04

James McComb

'if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work. This is counterproductive since those comments may be the keys or ideas that I need to incorporate to get the project on the right track.' This line shows something important in the classroom and in the real world, what's the point of expressing our ideas if no one can interpret them.

Reply
Posted: January 26, 2009 16:58

Michael Fried

“Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work.” It gives a chance for the client and or friends to let you know things they like and did not like so maybe you can fix it to make it better. If it is for a client then they can tell you how they like and prefer it so you can get paid. I was glad someone wrote about this because not all criticism is bad. Contstructive feedback gives the artist a chance to look at his work and have people tell him high points and low points about it.

Reply
Posted: January 26, 2009 19:18

Llay'n M.

"Constructive criticism is the key to a great piece of design work." constructive criticism is vital for learning. Its difficult for a person to see their own mistakes, so it is very beneficial to get an insight on how your mistakes are viewed from the outside. Sometimes I take criticism hard as well, depending on the manner the criticizer is speaking to me and their intentions of what they want me to get out of it. I'm learning and am always willing to hear constructive criticism as long as it helps me.

Reply
Posted: January 26, 2009 19:50

Pedro Recio

“Thankfully these days I am a lot more comfortable with that part of the design process, since it is something we have done in every Valencia course. It’s a good skill to develop a familiarity with, since it will be necessary when we are out working in the real world. I still get nervous though!” It gives me great comfort knowing this skill is something that is developed and not something that everyone has naturally; knowing I am not the only one who is pretty nervous when it comes to public speaking. But even better is knowing I will get a chance to practice this skill and further develop it in the classroom. From now on, I will definitely be seeing constructive criticism as…just that, constructive.

Reply
Posted: May 13, 2009 12:23

Berlinda "Nina-B" Graves

There have been plenty of times that I would take feedback as a way to broaden any ideas I would have already set in my mind when coming to my projects. No problem, I'd listen and try to see it from that person's perspective. Then there were times when I would be with a few of my classmates and they would recommend something and I'd be like "What? Are you Serious? I'm listening, but this is the direction I want to go. I've been with the client or I've studied and worked on this project, I know what's up. You are only viewing from the outside without knowing what I am dealing with." We have all said that or had it in the back of our minds. But, we have to remember that feedback is a good thing. Maybe you were sipping a lil' too much of that latte in the wee hours of the morning stuck on one concept. That's all that you see. When a person gives feedback, they too are speaking from what they see. They were not there when you were designing, but somehow found something that you might have missed or maybe a solution that didn't come to you. That can make or break a design. So it is good to see from another perspective. Good designers keep an open mind. You may never know what you make come up with.

Reply
Posted: May 19, 2009 11:25

erika Ruvalcaba

I noticed too that the times when I am particularly struggling with a project, if someone critiques it in a that I perceive as negative or says they do not understand what I am trying to express, that I have a tendency to get defensive about my work i chose this line because i think getting student critques is a good start to becoming not too sensitive, afterall once you become a perfessional you will be working with clients who are paying you and expecting something very specific. i am sure their comments about your work may be a little more critical and perhaps sometimes farther tha the original vision you may have had.

Reply